You are Johnny Depp. Your career, which relies heavily on the warmth and fondness that arise whenever your name—or that of Captain Jack Sparrow—is mentioned, is essentially in ruins.
A chaotic and highly publicized array of accusations concerning on-set assaults (including a settled lawsuit) and domestic violence (which you have denied), along with high-profile defamation trials, have collectively damaged your previously pristine reputation. Your most recent significant franchise role, portraying Gellert Grindelwald in the Harry Potter Fantastic Beasts series, came to an end when Warner Bros. requested your resignation following your defeat in a libel case against the Sun newspaper for branding you a “wife beater.”
Since then, you have had limited significant roles. Meanwhile, years of extravagant spending habits have led you to acquire a private island and a complete French village (in addition to nearly enough wine to intoxicate the rest of the country) and accumulating debts that rival those of some of the world’s most extravagant small nations.
What are your next steps?
Interestingly enough, for your first significant Hollywood film following the conclusion of your defamation trial against ex-partner Amber Heard (a case you largely triumphed in, with Heard being ordered to pay you $10 million US regarding her abuse accusations), you have opted for Ebenezer. This is a cherished yet repeatedly retold story. To some, this choice may seem more like a public relations strategy than a genuinely entertaining film.
Upon reflection, perhaps remaking Charles Dickens’s A Christmas Carol holds some merit. The narrative follows the frugal Scrooge as he learns to embrace Christmas and humanity through visits from one ghost and three spirits, all set in Victorian England. You once again have the opportunity to navigate the grimy streets of London, using the off-putting to Brits accent you’ve developed over your career, which is convincing to North Americans.
However, as you stride confidently in meticulously worn cloaks and time-appropriate whimsical hats, it may prove challenging for audiences to recapture the fondness they once experienced when watching Edward Scissorhands, Sweeney Todd, or even your portrayal of Willy Wonka in Charlie and the Chocolate Factory. They used to admire you, didn’t they?
This reasonable comeback feels remarkably similar. Can’t they find it in themselves to appreciate you once more?
-
REVIEW
Apple TV’s Nocturne is Nordic noir by the numbers
-
REVIEW
Wild Horse Nine is a bleak, hopeless sign of the times. You’re going to love it
To be frank, this outing is not bad at all. Grinning and grimacing alongside the best of them, your wide-eyed comedic outbursts and heartfelt, sentimental speeches guide audiences through Dickens’s classic, albeit somewhat saccharine, narrative of transformation from bitterness to redemption.
While this isn’t a standout Depp performance, nor one that offers significant depth or innovation, it does resemble the roles you once portrayed. The quirky smile and casually humorous dialogue that supported blockbuster films are still evident. That must hold some value, right?
Moreover, you are supported by an impressive cast: Ian McKellen as your cautionary-tale business partner Jacob Marley, Rupert Grint as your overworked and underappreciated assistant Bob Cratchit, and Tramell Tillman as the ominous, pagan-like Ghost of Christmas Present.

Tramell Tillman, left, portrays the Ghost of Christmas Present alongside Johnny Depp’s Ebenezer Scrooge in Ebenezer. (Jaap Buitendijk/Paramount Pictures)
Each actor fulfills their role: delivering memorable lines from effectively archetypical — and necessarily one-dimensional — characters. Their purpose is to ensure your unlikable protagonist endures enough trials to, by the conclusion, seem relatable, humanized, and deserving of societal acceptance.
In fact, it’s all so familiar and characteristically Depp that audiences may find themselves anticipating Helena Bonham Carter’s face to appear around every shadowy, cobblestoned corner. Director Ti West (MaXXXine, Pearl, X) tries to inject his distinctive campy-horror style into the source material, but rather than achieving the captivating genre blend of something like Tim Burton’s Scissorhands, what results is more akin to a community theater production.
There are haphazard additions of clanking chains and wailing phantoms reminiscent of Fleet Street’s central casting. West’s few original takes seem to aim for humor but land as bluntly offensive. For instance, instead of Dickens’s trembling child-spirits symbolizing “ignorance” and “want,” we encounter creatures more akin to Dr. Seuss’s Thing 1 and Thing 2, shrieking and scampering across the floor like tiny, translucent ankle-biters from the underworld.
Redemption roulette
So, why did you pursue this, Johnny? Upon reflection, relying on this now-cliché narrative instead of seeking reinvention perfectly suits your current situation. You are not the first celebrity to inspire “fall from grace” headlines. In fact, a common thread unites many of the numerous attempts to reclaim lost status.
There have been less successful efforts, such as Will Smith’s embarrassingly self-flagellating Emancipation, which tells the story of a man who endured relentless and brutal beatings, with images of his whip-scarred back aiding in the abolition of slavery. Similarly, Kevin Spacey’s amateurish The Man Who Drew God revolves around a blind man wrongfully accused of child sexual abuse. Additionally, there’s Armie Hammer’s Citizen Vigilante or Jonathan Majors’s Run Hide Fight: Infidels, both depicting a solitary man battling those the films portray as scoundrels.
Conversely, there have been more successful comebacks. Winona Ryder, after her criminal conviction, made a return with a small role in Black Swan, but her true resurgence began with her portrayal of the endlessly self-sacrificing mother in Stranger Things. After gaining a reputation for lackluster performances both on set and at the box office, Mickey Rourke made a (temporarily) triumphant comeback as the battered yet noble lead in The Wrestler.
-
REVIEW
Will Smith’s comeback, Emancipation, reduces a slave narrative to an action film
-
REVIEW
Tom Cruise is fantastic in Digger. You might hate it
Robert Downey Jr. achieved perhaps the most remarkable comeback ever, transforming the public’s perception of his substance abuse and arrests into that of a world-saving, carefree billionaire altruist in Iron Man.
Naturally, a film’s quality does not correlate with whether a star is a good person or not. While not universal, the formula for success is fairly reliable: If you aim to restore a tarnished reputation following controversy, present yourself as a pitiable victim or a self-sacrificing hero (or both) in a drama that subtly reflects your own experiences.
While Ebenezer may be entirely adequate — and as inventive as the novella’s entry on “Simple Wikipedia” — it at least meets your requirements. Given that it is based on a narrative so effective at evoking goodwill towards humanity that it essentially shaped the modern concept of Christmas generosity, what more could you desire?